Sometimes it is just better to stay home.
Daisy Sanchez Garcia can tell you the wisdom in that sentiment.
In Oct. 2008, a series of unfortunate minor events turned a fun night out in Anaheim into a real life nightmare that caused Garcia to frantically leap from the window of a moving taxi cab near the intersection of the 55 and 5 freeways.
The evening began with Garcia giving her driver's license to an Anaheim bowling alley employee to reserve a lane for herself and her boyfriend, Raul Lopez. But Garcia and Lopez never bowled. After waiting two hours, they discovered the employee forgot their reservation and, worse, lost her driver's license.
Garcia's night was quickly spiraling out of control.
Danielle Le, the bowling alley's assistant manager, apologized and promised to pay for the couple's ride home to Irvine in A-Taxi, which had a contract with the business.
But a security guard accidentally ushered them to a Yellow Cab taxi driven by Abdurazak Farah, who was in a foul mood.
they reached Irvine after a 25-minute trip, Farah demanded payment.
Garcia and Lopez were shocked and outraged. They believed the driver was
trying to double dip because the bowling alley manager had promised to
pay the bill.
When they refused to surrender cash, Farah locked
the doors to the backseat. Yelling ensued. Lopez eventually climbed out
of a window and attempted to pull his girlfriend out of the window too.
Farah sped off, dragging Lopez for a distance and began a dueling match
with a horrified Garcia. She pressed the button to lower the window and
he pressed the button to close it as he drove on the 405 and 55
Garcia tried to explain what had happened at the
bowling alley and, in hopes of ending the nightmare, promised to pay him
all the cash she was carrying. The offer apparently wasn't good enough.
The driver wanted more, said he wouldn't stop and drove north on the 55
in the direction of Riverside County, according to court records.
that she was going to be raped, Garcia leaped out of the 55-mph cab,
struck her head on concrete and suffered bloody wounds that required
Farah wasn't finished. He stopped his cab, got out and began walking towards her.
When another vehicle pulled over, he got back in the taxi and sped away.
Police quickly found him and he claimed that he was unaware that Garcia
wanted to exit his cab.
County prosecutors didn't buy the story. They charged Farah with
kidnapping and false imprisonment. At trial, he claimed that he wanted
to call police about the fare but that his cell phone battery had died.
It didn't help his cause that a police officer testified that the cell
phone was working minutes after the incident.
A jury found Farah guilty and Superior Court Judge Daniel Barrett McNerney sentenced him to five years in prison, but suspended the punishment on the condition that he serve a 365-day jail sentence.
his appeal, the 39-year-old Farah argued that he was innocent of all
the charges and that instead of kidnapping he had made a citizen's
arrest of Garcia for trying to steal a cab ride. Alternatively, he
argued that there was no proof that Garcia wanted to exit the cab.
A three-justice panel at a California Court of Appeal
in Santa Ana ruled this week that there was “overwhelming” evidence of
Farah's guilt and that his claims otherwise were not reasonable.
evidence showed the defendant intended to turn Garcia over to the
authorities upon his receipt of the total amount of the cab fare,” the
opinion states. “No evidence showed the defendant ever attempted to
contact law enforcement during or after the incident.”
Farah's claim that he thought Garcia wanted to be in the taxi was
ridiculous given the fact that she jumped out of the moving vehicle.
–R. Scott Moxley / OC Weekly
CNN-featured investigative reporter R. Scott Moxley has won Journalist of the Year honors at the Los Angeles Press Club; been named Distinguished Journalist of the Year by the LA Society of Professional Journalists; earned six dozen other reporting awards; obtained one of the last exclusive prison interviews with Charles Manson disciple Susan Atkins; featured in Jeffrey Toobin’s The Best American Crime Reporting; and hailed by two New York Times Magazine writers for his “herculean job” exposing entrenched Southern California law enforcement corruption.